The World Needs a Netflix Style Rating System for Books

About three years ago, I signed up for a service called Netflix. When I first set up my account, I vaguely remember rating certain movie genres from 1 to 5 stars and then specifying how often I watched movies in those genres and finally rating a few specific movies I’d already seen.

At the time, I didn’t think much of it. Now, all these years later, I realize how profound that short questionnaire (and my subsequent movie ratings) was. Because…

It made Netflix psychic. I’m not kidding. It really is psychic with roughly 98% accuracy.

Each time I hover over a movie title, it tells me how much I’ll enjoy the movie on a 1 to 5 star scale (1 being RUNAWAYNOW!!! and 5 being OMG!!!FANGIRL!!!SQUEAL!!!!!). Not only that, it gives me the average combined rating of everyone else who’s rated the movie. Yep, two different ratings. What the world thinks and what I’m likely to think. If nothing else, it highlights my abnormal movie tastes.

Out of the dozens of shows and movies I’ve watched, Netflix’s personal rating has only been vastly off maybe three times. It’s like Netflix knows me (or at least my movie viewing habits) better than I do.

Sure Amazon, Goodreads, B&N, et al have star ratings…thing is, they only offer an average of everyone’s opinion without regard for individual tastes. There’s no cross-referencing going on. And in Amazon’s case, they don’t even take into account your own personal taste—I know this because it keeps recommending the second and third book in the Fallen series even though I gave the first book 2 stars. Definitely not psychic.

It’s why I wish some uber-genius would design an artificially intelligent rating system for books. Life is too short to suffer books you won’t enjoy. A Netflix-style system would make the authors happy because only the people who are likely to enjoy their books will read them and the readers would be happy because they aren’t likely to read books they wouldn’t enjoy. Win-win.

But, alas, if wishes were pennies…

This entry was posted in Everything Else and tagged . Bookmark the permalink.

5 Responses to The World Needs a Netflix Style Rating System for Books

  1. Belle Wong says:

    I like this idea! Not necessarily for me for Amazon, since I don’t do a lot of reviews there, but surely it would be just amazing if implemented at Goodreads. I’m already in love with that site for all its social aspects – now if it could tell me if I’m likely to like a book? Wow!

    • J. D. Montague says:

      I really wouldn’t care *who* implemented it as long as it was implemented, whether Amazon or Goodreads or a different website altogether. Any site who offered such a service would probably be rolling in it because it’d be the first stop for bibliophiles everywhere, not to mention the word of mouth advertising they’d get.

  2. Lizzy Ford says:

    Lol … very cute (and true!) Books are likley going to go the way of Netflix anyway, especially with the eBook movement. I do like your idea of a more personalized touch/psychic ability to predict books more suited to your taste. I have a hard time reading through Amazon reviews when I’m looking for books, because it seems like a lot of people don’t write really insightful reviews of the books. Makes it harder to judge. But if Amazon and friends could make better recommendations in a Netflix fashion … I might use them more. :-)
    Lizzy Ford

  3. Joe says:

    I laughed out loud at this post, because I’ve had the very same Netflix experience. It bugs me a bit, that someone so accurately calls my tune.

    And ditto on the book end of it. Life is too short to read bad fiction.

    If I want that, I’ll write it myself.

    l: Your Library: A Tale Not Told in Books

  4. How I wish goodreads, amazon, etc. would do that too. That’s the main reason I love Netlix so much. It’s awesome!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

Notify me of followup comments via e-mail. You can also subscribe without commenting.